10 observations from watching The Innocent Man

Good news, crime drama enthusiasts, documentary fans, and people needing another excuse to flee rural Oklahoma!

About a month ago, Netflix released a true crime docuseries called “The Innocent Man.” It’s based off the John Grisham novel of the same name and profiles two high-profile murder cases that took place in the 1980s in Ada, Oklahoma.

While exploring the cases of Tommy Ward, Ron Williamson, and other men imprisoned for crimes they claim they didn’t commit (and probably didn’t commit), the documentary seems to allude to the hypothesis that the Ada law enforcement officials were the real criminals in this case.

While I’m no lawyer and was too focused on winning a Facebook comment war with my brother-in-law to pay close attention to the story, I still had some thoughts about the show. So here are 10 observations I made while watching “The Innocent Man.” 

It painted Ada as a shit hole

Despite John Grisham’s assurance to viewers that Ada isn’t a bad town, the filmmakers seemed to focus a lot of the shots on the four whole members of Brother Wolf’s congregation, the industrial remnants of Ada’s prime, neighborhoods with overgrown lawns, and the town’s water tower. It kind of paints Ada in a terrible light. Even though the reality is that Ada is known for such attributes as East Central University, a beautiful historic district, and how amazingly efficient the law enforcement personnel are at putting people in prison.

There were a lot of legal terms

I don’t know if it is my Arts degree or the Anthem brew I was drinking that is to blame. But I had a hard time keeping up with all of the legal terms being thrown around. But I guess that’s why God invented google.

Confusion as to how people got laid in the 80s

The reenactments and supposed confession tapes show some interesting fashion and haircut choices. My millennial generation technically shouldn’t exist because I don’t know how anyone dressing like they did in the 80s could’ve ever gotten laid.

The preacher open carried

Tommy Ward’s preacher brother-in-law Bud Wolf is featured continuously throughout the film, almost as a foil for Tommy’s own life. Something that the documentary brought to the viewers’ attention is the fact that Brother Wolf finds the need to “protect” himself with a handgun in his own church. The fact that an Oklahoma preacher was openly carrying a gun in church didn’t surprise me. What did surprise me was how unsurprised I was that a preacher open carried in church.

There is no real reason for the death penalty

Near the end, the documentary informs us viewers that approximately 4% of inmates aren’t guilty of the crimes for which they are imprisoned. Combine that nifty little factoid with the atrocious recent history of Oklahoma’s botched executions and stories of people like Ron Williamson, who came within four days of his own execution before being found innocent of the crimes, and then try to think of a single reason why the death penalty should still be allowed in Oklahoma.

It’s odd that the evidence is just in a random storage unit

Now I don’t know a whole lot about forensics or evidence or anything like that. But it’s weird to think that the belt that was used as a murder weapon against Debbie Carter was just chilling in a plastic bag inside of a regular old storage container that theoretically could’ve been next to the unit my parents use to store my baby pictures and family heirlooms they can’t sell until grandma dies.

The crimes didn’t happen that long ago

With the advent of DNA evidence being used in court and things like body cameras keeping law enforcement more accountable, it is easy to forget just how recent these crimes and imprisonments of innocent people really are. In fact, many of the suspects and law enforcement personnel are not only still in Ada, but also rocking the same hairstyles.

The documentary kind of forgot about the women

I know that the premise of this documentary was to discuss the imprisonment of innocent men by possibly corrupt law enforcement. But for a documentary covering the murder of two young women in a state that is consistently rated high for female homicide and low for women’s life expectancy, you’d think it would pay a little more attention not only to the fact that these women were killed in cold blood regardless of who committed the crime, but also that the problem hasn’t decreased in the two decades since the Ada murders.

The law enforcement also seemed to forget about the women

If it is the case that law enforcement knowingly threw innocent men behind bars to appear to be “tough on crime” to the citizens of Ada, then it appears that cops were so obsessed with giving the town the illusion of security that they ultimately forgot to make women’s safety a priority by refusing to arrest the right men.

The Ada law enforcement personnel, OSBI agent, and DA looked like caricatures

In a fictional story, if you would have described an OSBI agent as a handle bar mustached man with dark glasses, the lead detective as a stocky dude with a constant scowl and daughter the same age as the murder victim, and the DA as a plump balding man with a southern draw and knack for story-telling, then you would’ve made a solid D in your creative writing class for lack of character depth. Yet that’s exactly what OSBI Agent Gary Rogers, Detective Dennis Smith, and DA Bill Peterson looked like.

One of those descriptions also describes Hayley. Follow her on Twitter @squirrellygeek

Support Local Media

Help keep The Lost Ogle in business. Join the TLO Membership Club today for only $5 a month!

More The Lost Ogle News

13 Responses


  1. That’s not Captain Dennis Smith, that’s spinning arm Johnny Ross friend to the Mattress Kins


  2. I loved John Grisham’s desk. I also wish he would foster me. I would sew for him.

    At least Ada didn’t have Joyce “black magic” Gilchrist, R.I.P., and Bob Macy, R.I.P. I seethe.

    Both counties excelled at convicting people using junk science like microscopic hair comparison, and secreters vs non-secreters, paid snitches, and my favorite, deliberately ignoring more plausible suspects because of drug connections to law enforcement.

    Those two guys are innocent, and that fat DA who convicted them knew it at the time, and even today he doesn’t give a shit.

    These cases prove one thing, if you’re a proud hardworking white man in America, THE MAN is going to bring you down. Not really, but I like saying THE MAN in all caps.

    If you haven’t seen this on Netflix, watch it.


    1. Yes! The DA Bill Peterson is a crook. He should be in jail in my opinion.


  3. I covered both trials. The prosecution just did a better job of proving the cases, so you really can’t fault the jury. Now…should they have been prosecuted in the first place is the injustice.


    1. That’s my point…the prosecution DID prove it. No DNA back then combined with weak defense.


  4. The DA is know as a chuckle head in legal circles.


    1. known


  5. I believe it is accurate to say the book by Grisham is a work of Non-fiction, and not a novel. It is my understanding it is the only Non-fiction work Grisham has ever published.


  6. I guess it’s been a minute since Ok has received some kind of national embarrassment. Glad they dug it up.


  7. Read Grisham’s, a really good source on this case.


  8. Something ate my morning comment.

    “Confusion as to how people got laid in the 80s

    The reenactments and supposed confession tapes show some interesting fashion and haircut choices. My millennial generation technically shouldn’t exist because I don’t know how anyone dressing like they did in the 80s could’ve ever gotten laid.”

    Lights were bad in the parking lots at closing time. The rest (lalalalalal) happened when the room was dark and the clothes were off.


    1. X
      Scooby Snacks
      Pills
      Ecstasy
      🙂


  9. There was no DNA and each man confessed and that was shown to the jury..why does every show have to focus on the women? The show wasnt about the women..it was about injustice. It’s sad the women got murdered for sure but it wasnt the focus

Comments are closed.

We encourage engaging with our content, however we ask that you follow our Comment Policy. Learn more.

Join the Club.

Become a Member

Help keep The Lost Ogle in business. Join the TLO Membership Club today for only $5 a month!

You may also like...